Judge Sets Schedule for Line 5 Contested Case Hearing

Facebook
LinkedIn
X
Email

MEA is taking legal action to stop Enbridge Energy from building a new 41-mile segment of its Line 5 oil pipeline in northern Wisconsin. Details about how and when that litigation will unfold came into focus this week when Administrative Law Judge Angela Chaput Foy issued a scheduling order for the contested case hearing, which is set to begin in August. 

 

What is a contested case hearing? 
A contested case hearing is similar to a court trial and is conducted by the Division of Hearings and Appeals. A hearing examiner, also known as an administrative law judge, runs the hearing much like a judge runs a trial. The parties can make opening statements, present evidence, call witnesses and make closing arguments. 

 

What is at issue in this case? 
Permits and other regulatory approvals issued by the DNR are being challenged. They include:

 

Who is challenging the permits? 

  • Midwest Environmental Advocates (on behalf of Sierra Club, the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin and 350 Wisconsin) 
  • Clean Wisconsin 
  • Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa 

 

When and where will the contested case hearing take place? 

  • Aug 12 in Ashland
    Opening statements & public testimony  
  • Sept 3 in Madison
    Public testimony  
  • Sept 4 – 12 in Madison
    MEA (on behalf of Sierra Club, 350 Wisconsin and League of Women Voters of Wisconsin) and Clean Wisconsin present their case  
  • Sept 15 – 19 in Ashland
    Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa present their case  
  • Sept 22 – 26 in Madison
    Enbridge presents its case 
  • Sept 29 – Oct 3 in Madison
    DNR presents its case 

 

Can members of the public participate? 

Yes.

Observing the hearing 
Members of the public may observe the hearing in person. The hearing will also be available by video and telephone.

Public testimony 
Public testimony may be given in person on August 12 in Superior and on September 3 in Madison. Members of the public who choose to testify are open to cross-examination by Enbridge attorneys.  

 

Learn more about our Line 5 work here. 

More News

Legal settlement leads to statewide environmental review of data center development in Wisconsin

A legal settlement secured by MEA on behalf of Sierra Club requires the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources to conduct a comprehensive statewide review of the environmental impacts of data center development. The settlement resolves a lawsuit challenging the DNR’s decision to issue permits for the Vantage data center campus in Port Washington without preparing a full Environmental Impact Statement.

Read More »

Wisconsin youth ask state supreme court to take up constitutional climate case

Fifteen youth plaintiffs represented by MEA and Our Children’s Trust filed a petition asking the Wisconsin Supreme Court to take up Dunn v. Wisconsin Public Service Commission directly, bypassing the Court of Appeals. Their case raises urgent questions of state constitutional law that are too important to wait years for resolution in the lower courts, all while the state continues to approve new fossil fuel infrastructure that exacerbates climate change

Read More »

Legal settlement protects wild rice on the Menominee Reservation

With legal representation from MEA, the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin reached a settlement in a lawsuit against the Department of Natural Resources over the use of an herbicide that threatened wild rice beds within the Menominee Reservation. The settlement provides new protections for wild rice while giving the Tribe a greater voice in decisions affecting a resource that is central to Menominee culture, history and self-determination.

Read More »

MEA clients in Pierce County vow to defend clean water victory after Ridge Breeze Dairy appeals ruling

Pierce County residents took legal action over a permit that failed to protect local groundwater. An administrative law judge sided with them, finding the permit gave the DNR no meaningful way to determine whether the dairy was complying with state groundwater quality standards. The farm has asked a circuit court to overturn the decision, but our clients are determined to defend their hard-fought victory.

Read More »